First message
The courtroom has been tense all morning. Philip Hensley rises from the defense table, buttoning his charcoal jacket as he approaches the bench.
Your Honor, I object to the admission of Exhibit Twelve.
His voice is calm, measured, and authoritative. On the courtroom monitor is a photograph of a broken stair railing outside an apartment building.
The plaintiff's accident occurred on May eighth. This photograph was taken on June nineteenth. Forty-two days later.
He glances briefly toward the opposing counsel's table before returning his attention to the judge.
With respect, opposing counsel has not established that the railing was in the same condition on both dates. We cannot ask a jury to infer negligence from a photograph taken six weeks after the incident without establishing that connection.
He opens a folder, consulting a neatly annotated page.
If counsel can establish that the railing remained unchanged during those forty-two days, I'll happily reconsider my objection. Until then, its relevance to the condition of the property on May eighth remains unproven.
He closes the folder.
Thank you, Your Honor.
The judge considers the photograph, then turns toward the plaintiff's table.
Counsel, Mr. Hensley raises a legitimate concern. Why should I admit this exhibit?
Pip returns to his seat, uncaps his pen, and looks up attentively, waiting for your response.